Plymouth September Sales Span $18,750 to $789,000 With Median Near $480,600
Plymouth recorded 10 deed transactions from Sept. 11 through Oct. 10, but only five carried disclosed sale prices, ranging from $18,750 to $789,000 with a median of $480,600.
PLYMOUTH -- Plymouth's recorded deeds for the period Sept. 11 through Oct. 10 show five transactions with disclosed sale prices ranging from $18,750 to $789,000, alongside five additional transfers recorded for nominal consideration that do not reflect market sales.
MARKET OVERVIEW Five sales carried recorded prices during the period, ranging from $18,750 to $789,000, with a median of $480,600. Five additional deeds were recorded for nominal consideration under $10,000 and are not counted as sales. With only five priced transactions, the sample is too small to characterize overall market activity as particularly active or quiet; it reflects a modest slice of deed filings for the period.
TOP SALES The highest-priced transaction was 2000 State Road, which sold for $789,000. Karen A. McMullen was the seller; Glenn Alan Cugini and Katherine Ann Cugini, as trustees, were the buyers. Close behind, 5 Mayflower Street sold for $780,000; David V. Brunone and Pamela J. Brunone sold to Robert Thomas Murphy Jr. and Stacia Theresa Murphy. At 21 Sheridan Street, the property sold for $480,600; the sellers were Benjamin E. Neading and the estate of Joseph C. Neading, and the buyer was Patricia Faustrum. At 83 Valley Road, the sale price was $469,900, with Joanne Rouston as seller and Resina Guidetti and Paul Brennan as buyers. A fifth sale, at an address not specified in the deed record, closed for $18,750; Melissa L. Lindstrom was the seller and Jeffrey S. Hill and Mary E. Hill, as trustees, were the buyers.
NEIGHBORHOOD BREAKDOWN State Road saw two recorded transactions this period: the $789,000 sale at 2000 State Road and a separate nominal-consideration transfer at 1102 State Road. No other street names repeated among the priced sales. By price tier, three sales fell under $500,000: 21 Sheridan Street ($480,600), 83 Valley Road ($469,900) and the unaddressed $18,750 transaction. Two sales fell in the $500,000-to-$1 million range: 2000 State Road ($789,000) and 5 Mayflower Street ($780,000). No sales exceeded $1 million during the period.
MARKET NOTES Five of the 10 recorded deeds were nominal-consideration transfers rather than market sales. Based on shared surnames, several of these appear to be transfers within the same family or into a trust: Michelle Denise Foley transferred 45 High Pine Drive to herself and Matthew Paul Gindel as trustees; John Michael Kowalski and John Domenic Kowalski transferred 1102 State Road to John Michael Kowalski; Philip A. Murphy Jr. and Lorraine P. Murphy transferred 17 Belltree to Philip A. Murphy Jr.; and Susan Ocampo and Susan Marie Nilsen transferred 7 Allerton Street to Susan Marie Nilsen as trustee of the Plymouth Family Trust. A fifth nominal transfer, at 4 Bethpage Lane, moved from Long Pond Golf Corp. to Mark A. Ridder as trustee and the Residences at Waverly Oaks Association Trust; deed records do not indicate a family relationship in that transaction. No bedroom, bathroom or square-footage data were available in the deed records for any property, so price-per-square-foot comparisons could not be calculated. Property type (single-family, condominium or multi-family) is also not specified in the available deed data.
Recorded Deeds
Source: Registry of Deeds. Sale amounts shown as recorded; transfers without a disclosed consideration are noted as such.
| Date | Address | Grantor | Grantee | Sale Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11 | 2000 State Rd See Book | Mcmullen Karen A | Cugini Glenn Alan Tr.; Cugini Katherine Ann Tr. | $789,000 |
| Sep 11 | 5 Mayflower St See Book | Brunone David V; Brunone Pamela J | Murphy Robert Thomas Jr.; Murphy Stacia Theresa | $780,000 |
| Sep 11 | 83 Valley Rd See Book | Rouston Joanne; Rouston Joanne M | Guidetti Resina; Brennan Paul | $469,900 |
| Sep 11 | (no address) | Lindstrom Melissa L; Lindstrom Melissa L Tr. | Hill Jeffrey S Tr.; Hill Mary E Tr. | $18,750 |
| Sep 11 | 4 Bethpage Ln See Book | Long Pond Golf Corp | Ridder Mark A Tr.; Residences At Waverly Oaks Assn Trust | Nominal |
| Sep 11 | 17 Belltree See Book | Muprhy Philip A Jr.; Murphy Lorraine P | Murphy Philip A Jr. | Nominal |
| Sep 11 | 7 Allerton St See Book | Ocampo Susan; Nilsen Susan Marie | Nilsen Susan Marie Tr.; Plymouth Family Trust | Nominal |
| Date | Address | Grantor | Grantee | Sale Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14 | 21 Sheridan St See Book | Neading Benjamin E; Neading Joseph C Est | Faustrum Patricia | $480,600 |
| Sep 14 | 45 High Pine Dr See Book | Foley Michelle; Foley Michelle Denise | Foley Michelle Denise Tr.; Gindel Matthew Paul Tr. | Nominal |
| Sep 14 | 1102 State Rd See Book | Kowalski John Michael; Kowalski John Domenic | Kowalski John Michael | Nominal |
Compiled from official town feeds, community organizations, and local press. Outside reporting is attributed inline.
Share this story
Know someone in Plymouth County who follows town government? Share Townbrief Plymouth County: they can sign up free.